How Do You Identify A Topic And How Many Topics Should A Paper Contain
Monday, January 20, 2020
Surviving The Last Plantation :: essays research papers fc
Self-preservation, natures first great law,All the creatures, but man, doth awe.-Andrew MarvelleLove, family, and small thrills are but three things to live for. Sometimes they are the only things to live for. Sometimes they are what drive us to survive. For some of the inmates at Angola State Prison, there is little to live for and they still survive. Daniel Bergner once stated, "We live for whatever it is possible to live forâ⬠¦" (168). But what do the inmates of Angola live for? What brings meaning into their lives? Many of the inmates at Angola have been convicted of capital crimes. Many have no chance for parole. They still survive; they still find a reason to live. They find meaning in their lives.Before purpose and survival or redemption and salvation can be discussed, an idea of what Angola is must be produced. The warden of Angola is a large man by the name of Burl Cain. Some believe that he is the reason for Angola being what it is. Bergner believes different:The striking tranquility at Angolaââ¬âconfirmed by the ACLUââ¬â¢s National Prison Project and Louisianaââ¬â¢s own watchdogsââ¬âcould not be credited to Warden Cain alone. Twenty-one years ago conditions had been so anarchic and murderous a federal judge had ruled that the prison "shocked the conscience" and breached the Eight Amendmentââ¬â¢s guarantee against cruel and unusual punishment. Reform had begun then. [â⬠¦] [Warden Cain] aimed not merely at warehousing inmates safely, but at rebuilding them, at redeeming them, whether in terms of his Southern Baptist belief or in religious terms more broad ("Love thy neighborâ⬠¦") or simply in the sense of learning to live in some valuable way, without the impulses that lead to destroying othersâ⬠¦. (24-25)Though Bergner only carries this thought through the beginning of his stay at Angola, it is till a viable description of the institution. With this rough idea of Angola in mind, the inmates of Angola can be discussed. Their reasons for living can be shared.Carey "Buckkey" Lasseigne was convicted to live imprisonment at Angola at the age of 22 (Bergner 220). "He was separated from his wife the month after the killing, and they have since divorced. But they had been back together since his first year at Angola" (Bergner 221). That is part of what kept Buckkey going; part of what gave him a reason to live inside Angola. His wife is only part of the reason.
Sunday, January 12, 2020
Art is an expression Essay
Art to me is an expression. Society has a way of creating social norms, and through this influence people to become inspired to be different, to express themselves in many ways and to share with others this passion, in the form of art. Cultures have utilized art in the form of drawings, patterns, and techniques; for example the type of clothes they wear, and type of houses they live in. Art is everywhere. Albert Einstein once said, you could look at life as if nothings a miracle or as if everything is. I think that you can look at art in the same way. I remember watching a film in class on a man and a woman who were in charge of the community project that consisted of hanging sheets for miles. I have no idea why they would do that over a different art project, but I got their message. It was all about working together, doing something that was unique and of their own works, regardless of everyone elseââ¬â¢s opinion. They had to fight the system for a while before they were able to begin. Thatââ¬â¢s passion. After the readings I canââ¬â¢t help but to agree that art offers us a way to go beyond physical existence. What the author is saying to me is that art in every form changes our values our ideas in an effect change our lives. We are not robots, we donââ¬â¢t have to stay within regulations; we have the ability to be creative. Being creative is the most powerful tool we have some may argue. To touch back on why people make art, I can remember watching movies as a kid and there was this one kid out of the prep school that did wear the dress uniform to standard like all the other students. He was seeking to be different. Changing your uniform up a little to be different is art. Indians may paint their faces and their horses differently so that they stand out of all the others so that they can be found and identify. Same cases Indians made art was to distinguish themselves from other tribes as to not killà their own people during a raid or battle. I used to become stressed with school and/or with relationship issues so I started drawing. I never liked being told what to draw and how to do it. I mostly like to begin with lines and later find out it looks like something that was unplanned. The reasons why I draw was take my focus off of life. Sometimes drawing something that makes you happy can help you to recall memories from good experiences and can turn your day around. Art is my tool and is my passion.
Friday, January 3, 2020
Classic Literature for the Supernatural Lover
If you are you a fan of supernatural fiction, be sure to check out these superb classic novels that explore supernatural themes.à H.P. Lovecraft, a champion of the genre, once wrote, ââ¬Å"The oldest and strongest emotion of mankind is fear, and the oldest and strongest kind of fear is fear of the unknown.â⬠In that spirit, the list below includes some of the best examples of early speculative fiction, for modern readers who might like to know where it all began! The Mysteries of Udolpho (1794) by Anne Radcliffe This is perhaps the quintessential Gothic romance. It is filled with now well-established themes of physical and psychological terror, including remote and crumbling castles, a dark villain, a persecuted heroine, and supernatural elements. The extensive descriptions can be a bit much for some readers, but the effort is worth it in the end. The Strange Case of Dr. Jekyll and Mr. Hyde (1886) by Robert Louis Stevenson Although only a novella, this story packs a wallop. Split personalities, science gone wrong, an inquisitive friend and a trampled young woman. What more could one want from a supernatural thriller? Well, how about a number of film adaptations and incessant cultural references? You got it! Frankenstein; Or, The Modern Prometheus (1818) by Mary Shelley Shelleys work is the standard-bearer for the Romantic genre. The 1800s were a time of rapid scientific advancements, and literature of the time reflects these marvels and the fears and doubts they generated. Frankenstein is written in epistolary form and is inspired by a number of epic predecessors, including John Miltons Paradise Lost, Samuel Taylor Coleridges Rime of the Ancient Mariner, and, of course, Ovids Promethean myth. The Tempest (1611) by William Shakespeare The Tempest is a romantic tragicomedy inspired by the courtly masque that differs quite substantially from Shakespeares other works. It follows a neoclassical style and seems to comment on itself as a play quite openly, in what critics would later discuss in fiction as meta-narrative. Theatrical illusion mirrors story magic and supernaturalism to create a play that is both entertaining and self-reflective. The Turn of the Screw (1898) by Henry James The Turn of the Screw is a strange sort of ghost story. Jamess novella is perhaps most brilliant in its open-endedness and in its ability to create in the reader a personally significant confusion and sense of suspense. There is an evil hinted at throughout the story, but the nature of it is never really explained. Christabel (1797/1800) by Samuel Taylor Coleridge Coleridges long narrative poem was published in two parts, with three more parts planned but never completed. There is an odd sensation created by the rigid rhythm of the poems form (a consistent four beats to each line) juxtaposed against the mysticism of the tale itself. Modern critics have examined the poem through lesbian and feminist lenses, but it is the demonic presence which drives the action that makes Christabel so supernaturally appealing, even to the point of inspiring the great master of macabre, Edgar Allan Poe. Carmilla (1872) by Joseph Sheridan Le Fanu The lady Carmilla gains strange powers at night but is oddly restricted from crossing the threshold of a house. What rules keep her out without invitation? What mysteries of ââ¬â¹atà midnight drive her strength? This Gothic novella comes replete with castles, forests, and outlandish romantically-charged relationships between young women. The Complete Tales and Poems (1849) by Edgar Allan Poe Although Edgar Allan Poe wrote poetry (some macabre, some not) as well as being a literary critic and journalist, he is probably best known for his mysterious and imaginative short stories. Tales such as , The Pit and the Pendulum, Mask of the Red Death, and The Tell-Tale Heart, along with eerie poetry such as The Raven have made Edgar Allan Poe a household name worldwide.
Thursday, December 26, 2019
Feminism Is An Entire World View Or Gestalt, Not Just A...
ââ¬Å"Feminism is an entire world view or gestalt, not just a laundry list of womenââ¬â¢s issues.â⬠(Bunch, 1979:9) A critical quest for feminisms is the development of theories and analyses of power. One only needs to start analyzing the material of historical theorists to identify that there exists the need for feminist theories of power. Feminist contributions throughout history have been typically assumed much more utilitarian in their approach. The focus of historical theorists might often be described as more elusive and often entrenched within the patriarchal systems as opposed to rebelling against them, often adhering within the paradigm of systematic power instead of directly challenging the pervasiveness of power itself. Nonetheless, historical efforts have helped establish the need for contemporary feminisms to interrogate and challenge systematic power. Power has different manifestations whether systemic or hierarchical which can be viewed through a feminist critique. Several influential feminist scholars, including Mary Wollstonecraft, Simone DeBeauvoir, and Audre Lourde to name but a few help gain a deeper comprehension of the issue. It is evident that the manifestation of power has affected historical education, law, social training, and language. Education has often been used as a tool to facilitate power. Who has been provided with an opportunity to pursue an education is interesting to analyze. Historically, women and racial minority men were not provided with
Wednesday, December 18, 2019
Critical Discourse Analysis - 1510 Words
Critical Discourse Analysis Social communication is increasingly becoming a subject of scientistsââ¬â¢ discussions from different disciplines, as well as ordinary language users. In contemporary social sciences, especially in linguistics, we see a clear shift to discourse. Discourse allows us to talk about use of the language, as well as the language as a socio-cultural activity. In this sense, discourse, on one hand, reflects the social reality, on the other hand, it shapes it, therefore participate in the creation and pass on different values, ideologies and symbolic power. This essay aims to show the definition of Critical Discourse Analysis and also show how useful it is for exploring issues of power and inequality in relation to gender.â⬠¦show more contentâ⬠¦As pointed out by van Dijk (1993) one of the key objectives of the Critical Discourse Analysis is also the understanding of the nature of power and domination. In his view, power is based on privileged access to social resources, is widely c onsidered as securities, such as wealth, income, position, status, group membership, education and knowledge. However, dominance is defined as the use of social power by elites, institutions or groups, contributing to the emergence of social inequality (including - in political, cultural, class, ethnic, racial, and gender). The task of CDA is then highlighting the role of discourse in the producing domination. According to ââ¬ËStudying the Mediaââ¬â¢ dictionary, the complete and very well summing everything up definition of Critical Discourse Analysis is: ââ¬Ëâ⬠¦a means of analysing texts based on linguistics and in recent times the theories of Foucault. Discourse analysis identifies the culturally and socially produced sets of ideas and values that structure texts and representations. It helps to identify abstract and ideological assumptions about the world that may be implicitly contained in particular texts.ââ¬â¢ Fairclough developed a three-dimensional framework for studying discourse, where the aim is to map three separate forms of analysis onto one another: analysis of (spoken or written) language texts, analysis of discourse practice (processes of text production, distribution andShow MoreRelatedCritical Discourse Analysis ( Cda )1507 Words à |à 7 PagesCritical Discourse Analysis (CDA) is an interdisciplinary approach, which has been further developed on the basis of Discourse Analysis (DA) since 1970s. The insights have been expanded into a broader range of social, cultural, psychological and political practices. It is regarded as the textual study aiming to elucidate the abuses of power residing in the texts by analyzing linguistic/semiotic remarks in accordance with the existing (social, political, cultural, etc.) contexts in which those textsRead MoreA Critical Discourse Analysis Framework Essay1077 Words à |à 5 PagesMethodology A critical discourse analysis framework News is manufactured industrially and deeply influenced by the bureaucratic and economic structure of the media industry, by relations between the media and other industries, and by relations with authoritative apparatuses and institutions such as government. It reflects the prevailing values of a society in a particular historical context and simultaneously shapes the society in return (Fowler, 1991/2013). Although we cannot simply suggest anRead MoreA Critical Discourse Analysis ( Cda ) And Argumentation Theory860 Words à |à 4 Pages The current empirical study constitutes a critical discourse analysis of part of the discourse that surrounds the New Caledonian independence issue. It aims to explore audience response to political speeches, to investigate how politicians attempt to persuade people to follow a particular course of action, to link the notions of discourse and action to the cognitive dimensions of ideology and presuppositions, to further clarify various contextual factors, such as power configurations, to describeRead MoreCritical Discourse Analysis of the Movie Love Actually3536 Words à |à 15 PagesCRITICAL DISCOURSE ANALYSIS OF THE MOVIE LOVE ACTUALLY Love Actually is All Aroundâ⬠¦ Leon Koshcheyev English 2010 Professor O. Pimentel Love Actually is the ultimate romantic comedy written and directed by Richard Curtis. This film consist of dozens of different love stories that like a quilt are weaved together to make one story about love. It is about love in its many forms: love between family members, love between husbands and wives, innocent love, undeclared love, and romantic love. TheRead MoreCritical Discourse Analysis For An International Crisis Happening Thousands Miles Away Essay745 Words à |à 3 PagesMethodology Critical discourse analysis For an international crisis happening thousands miles away, it is not sufficient to be understood without acknowledging itself as a mediated complex. From critical linguistics perspective, Fowler (1991/2013) believes ââ¬Å"news is socially constructed. What events are reported is not a reflection of intrinsic importance of those events, but reveals the operation of a complex and artificial set of criteria for selectionâ⬠(p. 2). ââ¬Å"The news media select events forRead MoreCritical Discourse Analysis1347 Words à |à 6 Pages2.1. Critical Discourse Analysis (CDA): 2.1.1. What is CDA? 2.1.1.1. Critical, discourse and analysis Before beginning to address what CDA is, it is important to be clear about what is meant by the concepts of critical, discourse, and analysis: The notion of ââ¬Ëcriticalââ¬â¢ is primarily associated with the critical theory of the Frankfurt School where social theory should be oriented towards critiquing and changing society. In CDA, the concept of ââ¬Ëcriticalââ¬â¢ is appliedRead More Critical Discourse Analysis Essay2431 Words à |à 10 PagesCritical Discourse Analysis Jan blommaert and Chris Bulcaen makes a brief introduction to the study of Critical Discourse Analysis (CDA). CDA intends to use social-theoretical method in discourse analysis and is primarily linguistically based (Blommaet Bulcaen, 2000, p.447). It intends to analyze the structural relationships of dominance, discrimination, power and control through a textual study (Blommaet Bulcaen, 2000, p.448). Based on the assumption that social discourse is constructed andRead MoreSocial Transformations Of New Capitalism1611 Words à |à 7 Pagesdiscourse, and specifically discourse that reveals social transformations of New Capitalism, but to determine how societies work and produce both beneficial and detrimental effects and of how the detrimental effects can be mitigated if not eliminated (Christie, 2003, p. 203). Faircloughââ¬â¢s critical approach to texts societal elements affect personhood via discourse. Through his exploration of how the New Capitalism imposes constraints on individuals and societies, Fairclough argues that all peopleRead MoreDiscourse Features Of Mental Health1658 Words à |à 7 PagesIntroduction Discourse features of mental health community have been studied by many scholars. As Morrow (2006) described, there are numerous studies of doctor/patient interaction and of the interaction between other health care professionals and their clients. The research of online community that has gained increased attention by public media and health experts (Wolf et al, 2013) appeared, and there was also critical discourse analysis on the pro-anorexia movement (Knapton, 2013). From these researchesRead MoreMental Representation Of Critical Discourse Analysis2338 Words à |à 10 PagesMental representation in Critical Discourse Analysis Levels of analysis This phrase is applied to social sciences to point to the location, size or scale of a research target. It is unique from the term ââ¬Ëunit of observationâ⬠as the former relates to an integrated set of relationships while the latter is about the distinct unit from which data will be gathered. The levels of analysis are not mutually exclusive but an in critical discuss analysis research generally falls under micro level and the
Tuesday, December 10, 2019
Bariatrics As A Discourse Community Essay Example For Students
Bariatrics As A Discourse Community Essay Ashley Pirone English Writing 3306 Professor Victoria Papa September 25, 2015 Unit 1 APA Bariatrics as a Discourse Community ââ¬Å"Bariatrics is the branch of medicine that focuses on the causes, prevention, and treatment of obesityâ⬠(ââ¬Å"Medical Dictionary,â⬠2015). Bariatric surgery is a specific discourse community connecting individuals through mutual interests, shared knowledge, and expertise of treating obese populations. The field of bariatric surgery is a discourse community with several purposes. It encourages innovative surgical and nonsurgical solutions in obesity care. It formulates hypotheses and develops and conducts experimental designs to test the hypothesesââ¬â¢ reliability and validity. Furthermore, it aims to stimulate discussion about its findings. Scientists, researchers, medical professionals, and other experts in the field of bariatric surgery submit their findings and must go through professional gatekeeping measures like peer-review before their work can be published. Once their findings are published, they can be accessed in peer-reviewed journals, magazines, ar ticles, and scientific databases. One example of a publication in the field of Bariatrics is, The Journal of Obesity and Bariatrics, which is an online international journal, published by the Avens Publishing Group, or APG for short. This journal was published on August. 9 2013, and is composed of many scientific and scholarly research articles about obesity treatment. The Avensâ⬠¦
Monday, December 2, 2019
Nursing Research Critique free essay sample
Reminiscence Therapy (RT) was first developed by Butler (1963) as a psychological intervention for older adults; however, research findings regarding its therapeutic utility as inconsistent and inconclusive (Karimia, et al. , 2010). Not entirely sure what reminiscence meant, I looked it up. According to the Dictionary. com (2013), reminiscence is the act of recalling a past event or experience; reviving a retained memory or event. Reminiscence Therapy involves the discussion of past activities, events and experiences with another person or group of people. It usually involves the aid of tangible prompts such as photographs, household and other familiar items from the past, music and archive sound recordings and is intended to aid in resolution of past issues or to connect to good memories, aiding in a sense of well-being. In this paper, I will be critiquing the article, evaluating the aspects of literature review in research that have been taught in NU310 over the past nine weeks to determine credibility of the study, reliability of the information and adherence to study guidelines. We will write a custom essay sample on Nursing Research Critique or any similar topic specifically for you Do Not WasteYour Time HIRE WRITER Only 13.90 / page Title/Abstract An abstract is a concise overview of the research information that includes the purpose, methodology, results and conclusions of the study. It should be able to stand alone and ââ¬Å"allow a reader to decide whether or not to read the full text because your research and conclusions have relevance for his/her researchâ⬠(Millbrook House, 2004). The abstract in this paper is concise and inclusive of the purpose, results and conclusion of the study. I was distracted by the lack of basic information about Reminiscence Therapy and found myself searching for definitions to better understand the erminology in the study in order to follow the writer. The results of that search are shared in my introduction. Despite the lack of definition, I did find the writers were clear in their purpose and indicated enough information regarding the outcomes that the analysis met the requirements. Based on this information and the literature reviews included in the study, I find the title to be appro priate, especially the portion ââ¬Å"an empirical studyâ⬠as it lets the reader know up front that this is an empirical study, which does not use a scientific method or theory. Problem/Purpose Statement The introduction of this study begins with a broad statement regarding the research findings of reminiscence therapy and its therapeutic use being inconsistent and inconclusive. The writers launch right into a review of the literature, leading the reader down a twisting path of studies that result in greatly varying outcomes. The problem statement seems to be the lack of consistent and conclusive outcomes from past reminiscence therapy studies, but itââ¬â¢s not 100% clear. In one paragraph the writers indicate in ââ¬Å"reviewing 57 controlled studies to assess the effects of psychotherapy and other behavioral interventions on clinically depressed older adults â⬠¦cognitive behavioral therapy and reminiscence therapy are particularly well-established and acceptable forms of depression treatmentâ⬠(Karimia, et al. , 2010). But quickly follow with a statement that ââ¬Å"Lin, Dai, and Hwang (2003) carried out a systematic review [and] reported a lack of consistency in the findings of the research on therapeutic utility of reminiscenceâ⬠(Karimia, et al. , 2010). Not until the end of the introduction do the writers loosely define reminiscence and its usefulness in therapy. It is then that they hypothesize that integrative and instrumental intervention will produce statistically significant reduction in depression symptoms in the elderly. This statement defines to me that the purpose of this study is to show that integrative and instrumental reminiscence interventions will decrease the depressive symptoms in the older adult population. Literature Review/Theoretical Framework A strong review of the literature is present in the paper. The writers have acknowledged studies that resulted in inconsistent and inconclusive outcomes and the evolvement of the work done in relation to reminiscence therapy by other researchers. According to Karimia, et al. (2010); Watt, Wong and Cappeliez took the first steps toward removing the ambiguity of working with reminiscence by applying a widely accepted taxonomy and focusing on specific aspects within the classification. They noted identifying integrative and instrumental reminiscences as being particularly beneficial for positive adaptation and psychological well-being in older age. While the title of the paper implies this study to be empirical in nature, it seems this information is the theoretical rationale that this study is based upon. The integrative reminiscence process is credited with aiding in the resolution of self worth, conflict resolution and integration of past and present while the instrumental reminiscence process ââ¬Å"involves remembering past plans and goal-directed activities, recalling how one coped with past problems, and drawing from past experience to solve the present problemsâ⬠(Karimia, et al. , 2010). Design The study employed a three-group preââ¬âpost-test design with random allocation to instrumental or integrative reminiscence or an active social discussion control conditionâ⬠(Karimia, et al. , 2010). Pre-test/post-test designs are often used in behavioral research, primarily for the purpose of comparing groups and measuring change resulting from experimental treatments (interventions). The intervention, short form group sessions, were conducted by a masterââ¬â¢s level therapist who was supervised by a masterââ¬â¢s level clinical psychologist. Pretesting in this study included the MMSE, GDS-15 and a demographic questionnaire. All assessments were conducted by the clinical psychologist, who was not the therapist leading the intervention, and was blind to the subjectsââ¬â¢ assigned intervention group. Post testing included the administration of the GDS-15 only. Participants were randomized into three groups, one group serving as the control group. Designs that involve collecting data from different groups and examining the differences between groups are also called mixed-design groups. Sample Methodology/Patient Rights The sample group for this study was obtained from volunteers who lived at the Kahrizak Nursing Home located in Iran. Participants were selected ased on five inclusion and three exclusion criteria, some of which was discussed in the previous paragraph. There were 109 volunteers, 94 of whom passed the initial interview and moved on to be assessed for eligibility in the study. Forty-eight participants met the inclusion criteria. From those 48 participants, 39 were randomly selected and placed into study groups. ââ¬Å"In order to form matched groups in terms of depression severity, and gender, participants were systematically divided into three groups, and were then randomly assigned to the three conditions of intervention (integrative, instrumental, or social discussion) (Karimia, et al. 2010). Ten participants were excluded from the study during the eligibility trials due to illness. Proper attention was paid to the participantsââ¬â¢ ethical rights to ensure understanding of the studyââ¬â¢s purpose and that language and educational barriers were addressed. Interviews were conducted to assess the ability of prospective participants to understand and speak Persian at the onset of the study and verbiage in the GDS-15 and MMSE were modified to make the content culturally suitable with respect to the community and participants. The final sample included 29 participants (12 men and 17 women); 10 in the integrative reminiscence group, nine in the instrumental reminiscence group, and 10 in the social discussion group. The age of the participants ranged from 64 to 87; the distribution of genders within each group being 59% women and 41% men. Level of depression on the GDS-15 prior to the interventions revealed that across the three groups, the participants demonstrated equal amounts of mild, moderate, and severe symptoms of depression. Data Collection/Reliability Study participants were administered the MMSE, the GDS-15, and a demographic questionnaire to obtain quantifiable data used in the study. The MMSE, a short, structured interview, measured the cognitive state of each candidate. A score of greater than 21, on a scale of 0-30, was used as exclusion criteria to determine those who were not cognitively able to participate. Depression symptoms were measured with the GDS-15. Scores of 0ââ¬â4 are considered normal; 5ââ¬â8 indicate mild; 9ââ¬â11 moderate; and 12ââ¬â15 indicate severe depression symptoms. There was not an exclusion factor for this test. According to Polit Beck (2010), the quality of interview information and reliability of data relies heavily on interviewer proficiency and consistency. The clinical psychologist, masters prepared, was blinded to the subjectsââ¬â¢ intervention group. The role of the psychologist was to conduct all of the interviews and testing. ââ¬Å"All the questions of the MMSE, GDS-15, and the demographic questionnaire were asked orally and the oral answers were written down by the psychologistâ⬠(Karimia, et al. , 2010). Three distinct groups were established by randomization of study participants who met inclusion criteria; the integrative reminiscence group, the instrumental reminiscence group, and the social discussion group. Randomization to treatment conditions is noted by Polit Beck (2010) to provide the best control method for managing validity threats to a study. Each study group had six weekly sessions of 90 min each focusing on a weekly theme, conducted by a masters prepared therapist and supervised by a psychologist, yet not the psychologist who conducted the pre-testing to avoid testing confounding. At the conclusion of the intervention, weekly sessions, participants were again assessed on the GDS-15 by the clinical psychologists. Data Analysis In this study, ââ¬Å"analysis of covariance (ANCOVA) was used to determine differences in the depression scores between pre-test and post-test in the three groups, taking into account the effect of pre-test scores (depression severity) as a covariate variableâ⬠(Karimia, et al. , 2010). ANCOVA is a statistical control used to remove the effect of a confounding variable when other control methods may not have achieved comparability. The depressive symptoms of the integrative reminiscence group were significantly lower than those of the control group, yet there was little difference in the instrumental reminiscence group and the control group. The mean score of the integrative group at pre-test (9. 40) and the instrumental group at pre-test (9. 22) were both within the range for moderate depression. The mean score of each group at post-test improved, integrative (4. 70) and instrumental (7. 0), but only the integrative group returned to normal on the GDS-15 scale. The findings suggest that integrative reminiscence intervention was better than instrumental reminiscence intervention for reducing symptoms of depression. Discussion The writers note that in the Watt Cappeliez (2000) study, both the integrative and instrumental studies resulted in significant reduction in depression symptoms. At first look, it appears the integrative reminiscence interventions were very effective in returning an older adult participant to within normal range on the depression scale (GDS-15) yet the instrumental reminiscence interventions were not. However, once the researchers compared the data using the Scheffe test, the results for neither were statistically significant. Despite that, there was an apparent change in the perception of depressive symptoms in the participants as indicated by both mean scores moving from the moderately depressed range to the mild or normal range. Limitations to the study were noted by the writers as no follow-up study to discover the level of stability of the interventions effects, small sample size and the reliance on a single measure of depressive symptoms as an outcome measure. I also see the convenience sample taken from the nursing home to be another limitation of the study. As the writers note, in the Iranian culture, it is not customary for older adults to live in nursing homes. Residents of this nursing home could potentially be feeling a sense of depression, perhaps the attachment of a stigma, based on the lack of connection to family. I have concern with the adaptation of the GDS-15 and MMSE to allow for cultural sensitivity and wonder if the censoring of the content and language might have changed the test results. Conclusion The lack of a strong start in the introduction of this study left me wondering if the problem or purpose statement were missing, leaving the direction of the study to wander aimlessly. The six paragraphs of literature review that essentially indicated a history of inconsistent and inconclusive results would have caused me to not continue had this not been an assigned reading. More information in the early stage of the paper about reminiscence therapy and what exactly the integrative and instrumental interventions were might have held my attention and inspired me to read further for results. Instead I struggled to stay focused and absorb the information being provided. The researchersââ¬â¢ hypothesis stated that integrative and instrumental reminiscence interventions would produce statistically significant reduction in depression symptoms in the older adult population. The analysis of pre-test to post-test changes did reveal that integrative reminiscence therapy led to statistically significant reduction in symptoms of depression in comparison to the control group. While instrumental reminiscence therapy also reduced depressive symptoms, this improvement was not statistically significant compared to the control group. Even though the results may not have been statistically significant, I would have to offer that any reduction in depressive symptoms is significant in the mental health arena. This study does provide additional support for the effectiveness of integrative reminiscence therapy as an intervention for depressed older adults living. The general statement ââ¬Å"this study also provides support for the hypothesis that certain types of reminiscence produce their own specific effectsâ⬠caused me to read the article through once more to look for what specific effects were produced. I found no indication of what could be important qualitative data from the interventions that might also support the writersââ¬â¢ statement. Unfortunately, while this study was able to indicate an improvement in depression utilizing integrative reminiscence therapy, I am not convinced the results are reproducible. I would hesitate to base my practice on this study. References Dictionary. com. (2013). reminiscence. Retrieved from Dictionary. com: http://dictionary. reference. com/browse/reminiscence? s=ts Karimia, H. , Dolatshaheeb, B. , Momenia, K. , Khodabakhshic, A. , Rezaeid, M. A. A. Kamrani, A. (2010). Effectiveness of integrative and instrumental reminiscence therapies on depression symptoms reduction in institutionalized older adults: An empirical study. Aging Mental Health, 14(7), 881ââ¬â887. Millbrook House. (2004). Writing the Abstract. Retrieved from Writing a literature review as your dissertation: http://www2. plymouth. ac. uk/millbrook/rsources/litrev/lrabstrac t. htm Polit, D. , Beck, C. (2012). Nursing research; Generating and assessing evidence for nursing practice (9th ed. ). Philadelphia, PA: Lippencott Williams Wilkins.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)